Re: [AMBER] a question about resp restraints strength

From: Bahaa Mostafa <bmostafa.sci.cu.edu.eg>
Date: Sat, 16 Jul 2016 18:43:55 +0200

Dear Francois,
you have given me a potential answer for my question, i know that some of
resp options significantly affect the end results, i will try to find a
suitable set of them, but i want to stress out that the main problem is
that different restraint strengths result in not significantly different
charges like those listd below for pyrrolidine


mk (q0) qwt=0 qwt=0.0005 qwt = 0.001

-0.00989 -0.009890555 -0.007905866 -0.006100258
0.009841 0.009839467 0.010155813 0.010509111
0.109525 0.109527636 0.107825736 0.106155742
0.116778 0.116779355 0.114324612 0.112002456
0.003855 0.003855519 0.00337179 0.002933772
0.001553 0.001553338 0.001098908 0.000690422
0.011661 0.011660978 0.011610275 0.011555861
-0.01414 -0.014139331 -0.014252907 -0.01436943
0.074545 0.074544266 0.074959384 0.075366308
0.023573 0.023572687 0.024044117 0.024503789
0.061558 0.061557945 0.062094701 0.062603702
0.027171 0.027171044 0.027793792 0.028386356
-0.811833 -0.811833789 -0.810768214 -0.809735052
0.395802 0.395801441 0.39564786 0.395497222

with the following controls for one stage:
      ich = 0
      nmol = 1
      IQOPT = 1
      irstrnt = 1
      ihfree = 1
      qwt = listed in the table


the standalone versions released at
http://q4md-forcefieldtools.org/REDServer-Development/resp/ is a great gift
for me, thank you,
i compiled versions 1 and 2 successfully, but the error message "a.exe is
not a valid Win 32 application." appears when running the executable of
resp.f (either version)
i'm working on solving this problem,

thanks in advance

On Fri, Jul 15, 2016 at 7:22 PM, FyD <fyd.q4md-forcefieldtools.org> wrote:

> Dear Bahaa,
>
> Just run RED Server Dev + PyRED on methanol for instance and you will
> get default options is resping and corresponding inputs...
>
> if you download the resp version from q4md-forcefieldtools, new
> features were incorporated in the source code.
> http://q4md-forcefieldtools.org/REDServer-Development/resp/
>
> regards, Francois
>
>
> > i'm trying to get the partial charges for some small molecules, I do
> not
> > have AMBER and I am using the freely downloadable version of resp.
> actually
> > i am failed to compile the whole program so i composed a simpler version
> > from the original resp, this was done by collecting the subroutines which
> > are required for the fitting process in one file, i mad sure that this
> file
> > works properly by matlab calculations in parallel to each step even the
> > step of LU decomposition, employed for these tests were the methanol and
> > pyrrolidine molecules,
> > everything is ok in the simple version except that the strength of the
> > restraint seems to be not in effect, for example, a strength of 0.0005 au
> > produced a shift of 0.001 e from the unrestrained esp fit for few atoms,
> > and a strength of 0.001 au produced a shift of 0.003 e.
> >
> > these controls were used in all cases
> > ich = 0
> > nmol = 1
> > IQOPT = 2
> > irstrnt = 1
> > ihfree = 0
> > qwt = 0.001d0
> > by the way one stage-runs were used
> >
> > i don't know where, the problem, if existing, is supposed to be, is it in
> > the protocol of fitting or in my version, hope not,
> > now if any one could, kindly, help me or send me an executable (.exe) for
> > the freely downloadable version of resp
> >
> > kind regards ,
> > Bahaa
>
>
>
>
> F.-Y. Dupradeau
> ---
> http://q4md-forcefieldtools.org/FyD/
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> AMBER mailing list
> AMBER.ambermd.org
> http://lists.ambermd.org/mailman/listinfo/amber
>

-- 
*Disclaimer:*
This E-mail represents the views of its author only and does not 
necessarily reflect the opinions of Faculty of Science (*SCI 
<http://www.sci.cu.edu.eg>*). We do not assume responsibility for any loss, 
damage (including direct, indirect, punitive, special, or consequential 
loss or damage), which you may directly or indirectly suffer from this 
email or its contents or through the ways of handling this email which 
includes sending, receiving, replying, forwarding, deleting, saving or 
changing and adjusting its content in any way.
 
_______________________________________________
AMBER mailing list
AMBER.ambermd.org
http://lists.ambermd.org/mailman/listinfo/amber
Received on Sat Jul 16 2016 - 10:00:02 PDT
Custom Search