Dear Amber users;
    I'm performing a MMPGBSA study on a protein-protein 
complex.  The problem is that results from a compuational ala scan 
calculation are significantly different than the corresponding data from 
an energy contribution decomposition (per residue) calculation.  While 
these are not exactly the same quantities, I'm surprised they are so 
different ( ~ 3 vs 40 kcal/mol).  I'm wondering if anyone could clarify 
exactly how the energy decomposition is computed.  The same trajectory was 
used for both calculations, so there is no "perturbation" due to the ala 
mutation.  Therefore, I'd expect a difference on the order of 1/2 rather 
than 1/10.  It might be worth mentioning the largest differences are for 
Glu residues.
The options for the decomposition calculation are:
DCTYPE                2
#
COMREC                84-214
COMLIG                1-83
COMPRI                1-214
RECRES                1-131
RECPRI                1-131
RECMAP                84-214
LIGRES                1-83
LIGPRI                1-83
LIGMAP                1-83
Thanks;
-Sergio
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
The AMBER Mail Reflector
To post, send mail to amber.scripps.edu
To unsubscribe, send "unsubscribe amber" to majordomo.scripps.edu
Received on Fri Apr 18 2008 - 21:19:24 PDT